TRAINING VERSUS LEARNING
From News for Swim Parents
Published by The American Swimming Coaches Association
5101 NW 21 Ave., Suite 200
Fort Lauderdale FL 33309
By John Leonard
Last week I was speaking to a young coach who had just taken a new job.
His specific problem was that the coach that was there before he was,
had everyone “training hard” and had done a great job of selling that
concept. Everyone from 8 and unders to seniors was pounding the yardage
daily.
The new coach wanted to spend 6 weeks or so concentrating on skills
development, because in the first few days on the job, he noticed that
many of the swimmers were deficient in the types of stroke, turn and
start skills that would support them as they aged into older swimmers in
the program.
He’d laid out that plan to his parent group, including cutting back
practices from 2 and one half hours per day to just 90 minutes for the
older swimmers and 60 minutes for the middle groups and 45 minutes for
the youngest swimmers. This, consistent with today’s best advice to
dedicate oneself to “purposeful practice” of new skills if you hoped for
optimum learning….shorter periods of intense concentration, with little
to interfere with the concentration process.
He immediately faced rebellion.
Moms and a few Dads, called him to complain that important swim meets
were coming up and their little darling needed to “train” in order to be
successful. Interestingly, more than 70% of the calls came from the
parents of younger children. The coach asked my advice on how to
educate the parents on this issue.
Here’s my answer.
“Long practices, with high training volumes will make all swimmers VERY
good at what they are doing. Repetition builds habit. Habit stands up
beautifully under the pressure of competition…when in fact, nothing else
does….as the pain of competition effort removes all traces of
thought from the brain…..it becomes habit that the swimmer relies upon
to get him home to the finish.
“Unfortunately, if they are practicing poor technique, that will be
learned and habituated, just as well as good technique. And poor
technique makes you biomechanically inefficient at the time of greatest
stress. Hence you struggle more, go slower and your stroke collapses at
the end of races.
“This makes swimming a technique limited sport. Your child will be
severely limited by the degree with which they can perform the strokes
with good habits, instead of poor habits.
“Lots of training with poor habits will make a very poor swimmer. A
little training with good habits, will result in a good swimmer and one
that is “unlimited” in their future.
“Which one do you want for your child?
HINT: Get the strokes right FIRST instead of purposefully practicing
mistakes.
All the Best for Great Swimming Experiences!
John Leonard



